The Hard Conversations You Need to Have Before Marriage

The counselor slides a single sheet of paper across her desk and asks you both to read it silently before saying anything out loud. It’s a list of twelve questions: How many children do you want, and what if you disagree? How will you handle it if one of you wants to move for a job and the other doesn’t want to leave family? What does forgiveness actually look like after infidelity — have you discussed it, or just assumed you’d never face it? You’ve been together two years. You’ve talked about wedding colors more than you’ve talked about four of these twelve questions, and the realization sits heavy in the room before either of you says a word.

Proverbs was compiled largely under Solomon, a king whose own life became a cautionary tale about ignoring wise counsel in the biggest decisions — including his marriages. The book repeatedly contrasts the wisdom of many counselors against the folly of going it alone, and this particular proverb states the principle in its starkest form.

“Where there is no counsel, plans fail; but in a multitude of counselors they are established.” (Proverbs 15:22)

The proverb’s logic is worth sitting with: plans made in isolation, without outside wisdom, fail — not sometimes, but as the described pattern. Plans tested and refined by multiple counselors are established, meaning they hold up, they have real staying power over time. Solomon himself is the living illustration of what happens when this principle gets ignored: a man of enormous wisdom on paper who nonetheless made catastrophic marital decisions later in life, apparently without the restraint of counsel that could have challenged him. The proverb isn’t abstract theory to him. It’s a lesson written, in part, from his own regret. Applied directly to premarital preparation, this proverb confronts a common pattern head-on: many couples treat the engagement season as purely a countdown to a wedding day — venue, dress, guest list — rather than as the last, best window to actually establish the marriage itself through hard, specific conversations and outside counsel from pastors, premarital counselors, mentor couples, or even just honest conversations with each other about topics that have been avoided precisely because they’re uncomfortable.

It’s worth naming the specific categories of “hard conversations” too many couples skip entirely. Finances: debt, spending styles, who manages what and how decisions get made. Family planning: how many children, when, and what happens if you disagree or face infertility. Roles and expectations: careers, household division of labor, where you’ll actually live and why. Extended family and boundaries: in-laws, holidays, financial obligations to parents that neither of you has said out loud yet. Sexual intimacy expectations, and any past history that needs honesty rather than silence. Faith practices: how you’ll actually worship together, disagree theologically, and raise children spiritually. And conflict itself — what happens in the worst-case scenarios, addiction, infidelity, major illness, that no one wants to imagine but every marriage should have at least discussed once, calmly, before it’s ever actually happening.

Notice that this proverb doesn’t say a single wise counselor is sufficient — it says a multitude. That plural matters for engaged couples who assume that one honest conversation between the two of them checks this box. Two people who love each other, who are both invested in the relationship succeeding, are not always the most objective judges of where their own blind spots lie. A pastor who has walked dozens of couples through these questions will notice patterns neither of you can see from inside your own relationship. A mentor couple who has survived a specific hardship, like infertility or a job loss, can ask questions from lived experience that a well-meaning friend simply can’t. Seeking a multitude of counselors isn’t a lack of trust in your own judgment as a couple; it’s an acknowledgment that even good judgment benefits from more than one vantage point.

Avoidance feels easier in the moment, and it’s worth being honest about why: hard conversations risk real conflict, and risk discovering genuine incompatibility you’d rather not face after the venue is already booked and paid for. But the proverb’s warning is precise on this point — the plan doesn’t fail despite the conversation being avoided, it fails because of it. Silence doesn’t prevent the disagreement from existing. It just delays the disagreement until the stakes are higher, the options for addressing it are fewer, and you’re navigating it inside a marriage instead of before one.

Commit to premarital counseling with a pastor or licensed counselor as a non-negotiable step, not an optional extra. But you don’t need to wait for a counselor’s office to start. This week, sit down together with a short, honest list: How will we handle money — separate or joint accounts, and who tracks the budget? What are our expectations around children, and what if we disagree or face infertility? How involved will our parents be in our marriage, and where are the boundaries? How do we each define a fair division of household responsibilities? Pick two of those questions and actually discuss them out loud this week, even if the answers are uncomfortable, rather than waiting for a professional to force the issue later. Write down your answers, not just your spoken impressions, so you can return to them later in marriage when memory of this conversation has faded but the commitment behind it still needs to hold. If you find real disagreement on either question, resist the urge to smooth it over quickly just to move on to lighter wedding-planning topics. Sit in the discomfort long enough to actually understand why your partner sees it differently, and bring that specific disagreement to your premarital counselor rather than letting it quietly ride into the marriage unresolved.

The conversations that feel riskiest to have now are the ones that will spare you the most pain later. A marriage established on real counsel, not assumption, is a marriage built to last, and the twelve questions on that counselor’s sheet of paper are far less frightening once you’ve actually started answering them together.

Reflect

1. Which of the big premarital topics — finances, children, in-laws, conflict, faith practice — have you not yet discussed honestly with your partner, and why?
2. Are you and your partner pursuing outside counsel (pastor, counselor, mentor couple) before the wedding, or planning to figure it out as you go?
3. Is there a question on this list you're afraid to ask because you suspect you already know you disagree?

A Prayer for Today

God, give us the courage to have the conversations we've been avoiding. Forgive us for treating wedding planning as more urgent than actually preparing our marriage. Bring wise counsel into our path — a pastor, a counselor, people who will ask us the questions we're afraid to ask ourselves. Where we discover we disagree, give us patience and humility to work toward real understanding instead of papering over it. I don't want a marriage built on assumption. Establish our plans, Lord, through honest counsel and honest conversation, starting this week. In Jesus's name, amen.

Your Action Step

This week, pick two questions from the premarital conversation list you've been avoiding and have an honest, uninterrupted conversation about both.